Near as I can guess, this row of 19th century trinities in a delightfully secluded row near Rittenhouse Square was given a sort of Venetian stucco treatment in the early 20th c., complete with porthole windows, Juliet balconies, and mosaic tiles.
“TRINITIES,” IN PHILADELPHIA PARLANCE, are three-room, three-story houses — one room per floor — built between the 1790s and 1840s. They’re cozy, charming, evocative, historic, and, some might add, un-livable.
Rear unit of my ‘double trinity’ in South Kensington. The property consists of two back-to-back trinities under one roof.
Trinities are not for everyone, especially those with king-size beds. The smallest are only 100 square feet per floor. There’s a lot of going up and down stairs — narrow, twisty stairs at that. (Good knees a plus.) They’re fine for singles and couples; babies and dogs could be difficult.
They’re cherished archetypes in Philadelphia (I know there are also some in Baltimore and perhaps other cities, but Philly abounds in them). I’ve never seen or heard of such a tiny house in New York — correct me if I’m wrong.
You can see very early trinities lined up on Elfreth’s Alley in Old City, but trinities are not just historic curiosities. They’re all over Craigslist, and real-estate websites, for 249K and up in the very best neighborhoods.
I’ve owned a trinity in South Kensington since 2007 (all pictures in this post except the top one). I paid $135,000 for it. In fact, it’s two trinities, back-to-back under one roof. The rear unit was vacant; I fixed it up nicely, but it still took a while to find a tenant. One woman said the stairs gave her vertigo. Someone else used the word claustrophobic. But when an agile young man bounded up and down those stairs with a big smile on his face, I knew I had the right guy.
Trinities are found throughout the city, in Fishtown, Queen Village, the Graduate Hospital area, in Center City — often on narrow, cobbled alleys.
I fell in love with another trinity, above, near Rittenhouse Square, after spotting it for rent on Craigslist. I wanted to live in it so badly, I almost took it as a pied-a-terre, but decided that was silly (I don’t need a pied a terre, though I like the sound of it). This was last fall, and guess what — it’s still for rent! The price has come down from $2,000 to $1,850/month. This for a whole house, albeit a small one, in one of the best parts of town.
As of this writing, there was a trinity for sale for 299K in Center City, and one for 249K in Queen Village. This greedy old-house fanatic wants another Philadelphia trinity!
18 comments
Comments feed for this article
February 19, 2009 at 4:58 pm
Caroline
Trinities are totally livable! I lived in one when I first moved to Philly. As long as you use your space efficiently and live clutter-free, they’re so cozy. (Also, you have to be careful on those stairs after you’ve had a few glasses of wine.) I actually went to an open house for the first one you posted–the one that’s $299k. It’s wonderful! It made me wish I still lived alone. The seller really did an amazing job with it–the kitchen is adorable and high-end and the patio is very private and like a beautiful extra room. It’s on Quince, which is a great street, I think he’s selling all of his furniture with it. Anyway. I love trinities :).
February 19, 2009 at 5:09 pm
cara
Hey, Caroline, thanks for filling us in on that listing from the POV of one who’s actually checked it out. But if I don’t miss your point, you’re saying trinities are totally livable – for one person!
February 19, 2009 at 5:46 pm
Caroline
Yes! One person + one cat or one small dog.
February 20, 2009 at 12:13 am
Melissa
I’m beginning to understand more and more why Philly is called the “Sixth Boro”. A Trinity house sounds perfect for the minimalist. I have a slight problem with clutter (understatement) and don’t know what I’d do with my book collection, but it looks like a great concept.
June 10, 2009 at 1:55 pm
Beth Huerta
Hi !! That Trinity for $249 is mine and it’s still for sale! It’s a gorgeous house – completely comfortable! Interested?
June 10, 2009 at 1:56 pm
Beth Huerta
I can be reached through my realtor Carol Brown @ 215-528-1868
December 15, 2010 at 2:08 pm
Jenna
I’m moving into a trinity this week and was just googling “moving into a trinity” and came across this post. I am so excited to have a cozy little house. I won’t be alone however, I have a boyfriend…but we have the holy grail of trinities…one with an extra floor! Sooo in case you’re interested…it’s basement, living room, kitchen, bedroom/bath, bedroom. Yay!
I’m good with getting my bed up the stairs (I have a squishy double mattress and a frame that comes apart)…any advice on getting a couple of old, normal sized dressers up the stairs? I’m nervous!
December 15, 2010 at 4:26 pm
cara
Ummm…hire local movers experienced with trinities? Actually, I think you’ll be OK as long as the dressers aren’t oversized. Best of luck to you, Jenna, in your new trinity (actually, counting the basement, they’re all four stories), and many thanks for commenting!
December 15, 2010 at 4:33 pm
Jenna
movers…that’s funny. $$$$$$$$$
(this one’s 5 floors)
December 15, 2010 at 4:46 pm
cara
So we have to call it a…”quad” then? What neighborhood are you in, Jenna?
December 23, 2010 at 10:28 am
Joy
I grew up in Philadelphia. My best friend’s father had a photo studio in one of these trinities in Center City. We used to refer to these type of buildings as “father, son, holy ghost” buildings.
I now live in Brooklyn. My house looks like a West Philadelphia row house.
December 23, 2010 at 12:07 pm
cara
hi Joy, thanks for the reminiscence! Hard to imagine operating a business out of a Philadelphia trinity. I occasionally see a house in Brooklyn that reminds me of Philly. Just the other day, I noticed a pair of houses — frame I think — on Washington Ave in Clinton Hill, set back far from the street, with porches on top of a high stoop, and I thought “Philadelphia!”
January 1, 2011 at 4:17 pm
Joy
Come by Fuller Place in Windsor Terrace and you’ll be surprised! (A little more than a mile from where you are, I’m guessing!).
Windsor Place, between 10th and 11th Avenue smacks of West Philadelphia, too.
January 2, 2011 at 1:18 am
cara
hi Joy, good to hear from you! I *love* Fuller Place….check this out: http://casacara.wordpress.com/2008/12/25/prettiest-block-in-brooklyn/
Haven’t seen Windsor Place, though – I will take a look. (Know of any houses for sale on those blocks? If so, I’m interested!)
November 16, 2011 at 10:09 am
Jonathan Senker
My cousins bought a gut-renovated trinity on Naudain Street. The modern kitchen is the full width of the house, right behind the small front living room. There’s no bathroom on the main floor. Not for everyone, but I would take one in a heartbeat! Especially if it was a little less “gut” renovated.
I’m also from Philadelphia, living in Brooklyn. I don’t think it’s the “Sixth Borough.” It has a different feel.
November 16, 2011 at 10:23 am
cara
Hi Jonathan, nice to hear from you. I’m with you on the less renovated the better. Within reason! Yes trinities have undeniable charm. They are not for everyone though. Welcome to Brooklyn. There does seem to be a Brooklyn Philadelphia orbit that a lot of people are traveling these days.
January 22, 2013 at 2:02 pm
Megan Rye
Hello Fellow Trinity Enthusiasts, we are selling our trinity in Queen Village, Philadelphia, which has affectionately been restored to the original random-width pine floors along with 3 fireplaces. It’s in a safe, gated courtyard. We’d love it to go to someone who will enjoy it as much it as we have: http://goo.gl/rLPvR
March 17, 2013 at 9:21 am
Deb
My best friend’s family lived in two back to back trinities, the 1st floor had a doorway knocked through. They used to get furniture into the upper floors through the windows.